How do Brentwood and Maplewood compare side by side?

Brentwood is higher priced with a lower tax rate; Maplewood is lower priced with a longer restaurant and retail strip on Manchester Road. Figures are approximate (verify before relying on it).

Factor Brentwood Maplewood
Median sale price (listing data, early 2026) $535,000 $450,000
School district (named as a fact) Brentwood School District Maplewood Richmond Heights School District
Median days on market (listing data, early 2026) 8 days 12 days
Land area 1.9 sq mi 1.6 sq mi
Walkable area Brentwood Promenade and park Manchester Road corridor
Commute to downtown St. Louis about 13 min about 11 min

For school information, check each district’s website and the Missouri DESE report card for current data.

Where does Brentwood come out ahead?

Brentwood has the lower tax rate and somewhat larger lots. Streets in Brentwood tend to have more space between houses, while Maplewood’s density means smaller lots. The Brentwood Promenade is a compact shopping and dining area, more concentrated than Maplewood’s strip. A renovated 2,200 square foot house runs about $525,000 to $590,000 in Brentwood against about $475,000 to $540,000 in Maplewood, and both come in below the $625,000 to $725,000 I see for a 2,400 square foot house in Webster Groves.

Where does Maplewood come out ahead?

Maplewood has the lower entry price, the shorter commute and the longer walkable strip. The median runs about $50,000 to $75,000 below Brentwood for comparable houses, and the drive to downtown is about 11 minutes against 13. Manchester Road through Maplewood has more restaurants, bars and small retail, including Schlafly Bottleworks and Foundation Grounds, so more errands are on foot.

How do I choose between them?

Choose Brentwood if the annual tax bill, lot size and a more residential street feel matter most. Choose Maplewood if entry price and a longer walkable strip matter most. Walk both on a weekday evening and a Saturday morning before you decide.

What do the two have in common?

Both are small, close to downtown and mostly older houses. Each covers under 2 square miles, each is an 11 to 13 minute drive from downtown, and each has the old-house maintenance list: sewer laterals, electrical, plaster. Both have median prices below Webster Groves and Clayton. Look at recent sold comps for the exact street before you decide a price is fair.

What does the investor lens look like?

Both lean toward appreciation over cash flow. I see Maplewood cap rates of about 4% to 5.5% and Brentwood about 4% to 5% on stabilized rentals (approximate; verify before relying on it). Brentwood inventory turns over less often, so long-hold buyers there often source off-market. This is not investment, tax or legal advice: your lender decides financing, your CPA decides tax treatment, and an attorney reviews any lease or entity structure. Run an address through the cap rate tool.