How do Brentwood and Webster Groves compare at a glance?
Webster Groves has the higher prices, the older housing and the faster market. Brentwood has the shorter commute and the smaller lots. All figures below are approximate; verify before relying on them.
| Metric | Brentwood (63144) | Webster Groves (63119) |
|---|---|---|
| Median home value | about $252,700 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026) | about $391,700 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026) |
| Median sale price | about $292K (Redfin, zip-level, Mar 2026) | about $561K (Redfin, city-level, Jun 2025) |
| Average days on market | about 30 to 39 | about 4 to 5 (Redfin) |
| Population | about 8,100 | about 23,800 |
| Land area | about 2.0 sq mi | about 5.9 sq mi |
| Public school district | Brentwood School District | Webster Groves School District |
| Commute to downtown St. Louis | about 12 to 15 min | about 15 to 20 min |
| Median annual property tax | about $3,161 (Ownwell) | see the tax section below |
| Walk Score | about 62 | about 61 |
| Nearby parks | Brentwood Park, Memorial Park | Blackburn Park, Webster Park |
| Typical housing age | 1940s to 1960s mix | 1900s to 1940s |
Zip-level and city-level numbers are not the same thing. Redfin shows a $292K median sale price for the 63144 zip, while Homes.com lists Brentwood proper at a $950K median. The zip includes condo-heavy pockets and the city has more single-family weight. Always check which one a statistic is using.
What kind of houses are in Brentwood?
Brentwood has three price tiers, and most of the stock is post-war. Lots are small, mostly under 7,000 square feet, and the housing averages roughly 80 years old.
- $180K to $250K: condos and townhomes, mainly Brentwood Forest. Two-bedroom, mid-century construction, with HOA fees around $300 to $400 a month.
- $300K to $500K: smaller post-war single-family homes, mostly 2 to 3 bedrooms under 1,500 square feet on lots under 6,000 square feet. Most need updating.
- $500K to $1M and up: renovated single-family homes or new infill, still on small lots, at 2,200 square feet and up with 4 bedrooms and modern kitchens.
About 28% of Brentwood’s housing is multifamily: duplexes, fourplexes and small apartment buildings (NeighborhoodScout). Inventory is thin. Some months fewer than 10 single-family homes are for sale in the whole city.
What kind of houses are in Webster Groves?
Webster Groves is mostly historic single-family housing. Per NeighborhoodScout, 38.8% of homes were built in the 1940s to 1960s (ranches, capes, brick bungalows), 37.3% were built before 1939 (Victorian, craftsman, prairie-style), and only 4.8% after 2000.
The price range is wide because the city is several different markets:
- North Webster, near I-44: pre-war homes at roughly $300K to $450K that often need work.
- Old Webster, near the train station, Old Orchard and downtown: the walkable core, roughly $500K to $900K.
- Tuxedo Park and the streets near the high school: the upper tier, roughly $700K to $1.2M.
The price ranges are my read of the market, not a published statistic. Value measures vary by source: Zillow’s index shows about $391,700, Redfin’s median sale price is about $561K, and Homes.com lists $742,500. Use recent solds for a specific street, not any one headline number.
How long is the commute from each?
Brentwood is the shorter drive to almost everywhere on this list. Times are approximate drive times.
| Destination | From Brentwood | From Webster Groves |
|---|---|---|
| Downtown St. Louis | 12 to 15 min via I-64 | 15 to 20 min via I-44 |
| Clayton | 8 min | 12 min |
| Chesterfield Valley | 15 min | 20 min |
| St. Louis Lambert Airport | 15 min | 20 min |
| Forest Park | 10 min | 12 min |
| BJC / Wash U Med Campus | 8 to 10 min | 12 to 15 min |
Both have MetroLink nearby. Brentwood has the Brentwood I-64 station, with Richmond Heights on its border. Webster Groves has Shrewsbury-Lansdowne on its south end. Most people in both places drive.
How do property taxes compare?
Missouri assesses residential property at 19% of market value, then applies the local levy to that assessed value. A $400,000 home is taxed on $76,000, not $400,000. For the full walk-through, read St. Louis property tax explained or run your own address in the property tax tool.
In Brentwood, the median annual bill is about $3,161, with a 25th percentile of about $2,895 and a 90th percentile of about $6,182 (Ownwell, 2026; approximate, verify before relying on it). The levy funds the county, the city, the Brentwood School District, the Special School District, the fire district, the library district and MetroLink, among others.
For Webster Groves I do not have a verified median to publish. The Webster Groves School District levy is among the higher ones in St. Louis County, so a $700,000 home there generally carries a bigger bill than a $700,000 home in Brentwood. Pull the actual annual figure for the address from the St. Louis County Assessor before you write an offer.
What is there to do on foot?
Brentwood’s walkability is concentrated and retail-driven. Webster Groves has two districts that work as town centers.
Brentwood: - The Promenade at Brentwood (Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods, REI, Pottery Barn) - Eager Road and Hanley Industrial Court restaurants - Brentwood Pool and the Brentwood Recreation Complex - The Heart of Brentwood festival each summer
Webster Groves: - Old Webster and Old Orchard (Olive + Oak, Telva at the Ridge, Straub’s, 23 West Coffee) - Webster University campus and the Repertory Theatre of St. Louis - Webster Groves Farmers Market, Jazzfest and Community Days - Blackburn Park, Webster Park and the Greenway Trail
What goes wrong with each?
Every house I’ve seen in either place has a catch, and they are different catches.
Brentwood - Basement water. Many pre-1960 basements in 63144 take water in heavy rain. First Street data puts about 18% of properties at moderate to severe flood risk over the next 30 years (approximate; verify before relying on it). Get a flood and sewer inspection. - Small lots. Most are 5,000 to 6,500 square feet, and few homes have garages. - Aging infrastructure. Streets, sewers and water lines show their age in pockets. - Thin inventory. You may wait for the right house.
Webster Groves - Competition. Redfin shows homes selling in days and often about 5% over asking (approximate; verify before relying on it). Do not fall for one house. - Old systems. Galvanized plumbing, knob-and-tube wiring and stone foundations that need pointing. None is automatically a deal-breaker. I would budget $50K to $150K of capital work over the first five years on a pre-war house; that is my planning range, not a quote. - Taxes scale fast. Run the actual annual number, not just the rate. - Busy through-streets. Big Bend, Lockwood, Elm, Watson and Manchester carry traffic. The tree-lined streets are not the same on every block.
Which one fits an investor?
Brentwood leans toward small multifamily, and Webster Groves leans toward long holds. With about 28% of Brentwood’s housing in 2 to 4 unit and larger buildings, there are more small-multifamily deals to look at. Webster Groves is mostly single-family, so a rental there is a hold on a quality house. I run both with actual rents and expenses. See first investment property in St. Louis and the cap rate tool.
Which should I pick?
Pick on budget, commute and housing type. There is no better suburb, only a better fit.
Lean Brentwood if: - You work downtown, in Clayton, or at BJC and Wash U Med - Your budget is $250K to $500K and you want options - You do not need a big yard - You would rather have convenience than historic character
Lean Webster Groves if: - You want larger lots and pre-war architecture - Your budget is $400K to $1M and up - You want a walkable downtown - You plan to hold the house 10 years or more
If you want construction from after 1990, neither is the move; look at Chesterfield, Wildwood or O’Fallon. For urban walkability, the Central West End or Lafayette Square fit better. Schools differ by address, so check each district’s site and the Missouri DESE report card for current data.
How would I run this comparison with you?
I pull the last 90 days of solds in both places at your price, send you the numbers, and we drive both downtowns on the same Saturday morning. There is no obligation. You can book a consultation or run the affordability tool first.