How do Clayton and Ladue compare side by side?

Clayton is smaller, denser and closer to downtown; Ladue is larger, with bigger lots and a lower effective tax rate. Figures are approximate (verify before relying on it).

Factor Clayton Ladue
Median sale price (listing data, early 2026) $870,000 $1,400,000
School district (named as a fact) School District of Clayton Ladue School District
Median days on market (listing data, early 2026) 18 days 35 days
Land area 2.5 sq mi 8.5 sq mi
Lot size Smaller, urban Larger, suburban
Character Walkable, mixed density Estate streets
Commute to downtown St. Louis about 11 min about 18 min

For school information, check each district’s website and the Missouri DESE report card for current data.

Where does Clayton come out ahead?

Clayton offers walkability, a shorter commute and a lower entry price. It has a real downtown with restaurants, retail and a business district, so dinner, coffee and errands are within walking distance of many addresses. The drive to downtown St. Louis is about 11 minutes against 18 from Ladue. The median is about $530,000 lower, which puts the $750,000 to $1.1 million range within reach (approximate; verify before relying on it). Homes also sell faster, at a median of 18 days against 35.

Where does Ladue come out ahead?

Ladue has larger lots, a lower tax rate and more variety in land area. Its 8.5 square miles hold large lots, mature landscaping and many 1920s to 1940s estate-style houses. Clubs such as St. Louis Country Club, Old Warson and Bellerive are nearby.

How do I choose between them?

Choose Clayton if you want to walk to a downtown, shorten the commute, or spend $750,000 to $1.1 million. Choose Ladue if you want a larger lot and more space between houses, and your budget is around $1.5 million or more. Because the price gap is large, most buyers settle this question with their budget first.

What do the two have in common?

Both sit far above the metro median on price and both carry high tax bills in absolute dollars regardless of the rate. Both also have thin inventory relative to demand at their price points. As rentals, I see cap rates of about 3% to 4.5% (approximate; verify before relying on it), which makes them appreciation and ownership plays rather than cash-flow plays.

What does the investor lens look like?

Clayton condos are the more workable investment of the two, and Ladue rarely is. Clayton condos show cap rates of about 4% to 5% in my notes, with rental demand tied to the nearby universities and the business district. In Ladue, the capital per unit is large and rental demand is thinner, so most purchases are owner-occupied. This is not investment, tax or legal advice: your lender decides financing, your CPA decides tax treatment, and an attorney reviews leases and entities.