How is multifamily different from single-family?

Three things change: how value is set, how it is financed and how it is run.

Valuation. Houses are valued from comparable sales. Buildings with five or more units are valued from income: NOI divided by the cap rate equals value. A $20 a month rent increase across 8 units adds $1,920 a year of NOI. At a 6% cap rate that implies about $32,000 of value. A $50 a month increase across 12 units adds $7,200 of NOI and implies about $120,000. Those are illustrations of how the formula works, not forecasts, and the buyer’s cap rate assumption does most of the work.

Financing. Loans on one to four units look mostly at your personal income and have loan limits. Commercial loans on five or more units look mostly at the property, using DSCR, often with 20% to 25% down, a 5 to 7 year balloon and a 25 to 30 year amortization. They are relationship-driven, and local and regional banks matter. Terms vary, so ask a lender.

Operations. Eight units means eight leases, eight rent collections, common areas, shared utilities and unit turns to coordinate. The skills are learnable and different from running one house.

What does an 8-unit value-add look like in numbers?

On the illustrative deal below, the plan creates value only if rents rise by about 35%. The property is an 8-unit brick building near Manchester Road in Maplewood, built in 1925 and last renovated in 1995, with rents below market. All figures are assumptions, not a quote or forecast.

Item In place Stabilized (year 3)
Rent per unit $850 $1,150
Gross rent per year $81,600 $110,400
Vacancy 5% ($4,080) 4% ($4,416)
Effective gross income $77,520 $105,984
Operating expense ratio 38% 35%
Operating expenses $29,458 $37,094
Net operating income $48,062 $68,890

Purchase price is $920,000 for a cap rate in place of about 5.2%. Cash invested is about $292,600: $230,000 down (25%), $27,600 closing costs (3%) and a $35,000 repair and turn budget. At a 6% cap rate, $68,890 of NOI implies a value of about $1,148,000. At 5.5% it implies about $1,253,000. That is an implied gain of about $228,000 to $333,000 over 36 months, before the cost of renovating units beyond the $35,000 budget and before selling costs. The value moves a lot with the cap rate you assume. Test your numbers in the cap rate tool.

Where does multifamily show up in St. Louis?

These are the areas I look at first. Prices and building sizes are approximate (verify before relying on it).

Webster Groves, Kirkwood, Clayton and Ladue have almost no multifamily inventory, and most of West County is single-family. Rent growth and operating costs vary by building, so underwrite each one on its own rent roll.

How would someone work toward a first building?

One common path takes several years. It is not the only one, and your lender can tell you what they would need to see.

  1. Years 1 to 3: buy and stabilize a few single-family rentals. Learn tenant management, repairs and expense tracking, and build a contractor and manager bench.
  2. Years 3 to 4: meet several local commercial lenders. Understand their underwriting and open business banking with the one you may use.
  3. Year 4: search 5 to 12 unit buildings in one submarket, underwrite 30 or more before you offer, and negotiate a due diligence period. Inspect the roof, electrical, plumbing, mechanicals, sewer, and lead and asbestos. Stabilize operations in the first 90 days and begin the improvement plan.
  4. Years 5 to 10: add a second building after the first stabilizes. Ask a qualified intermediary and your CPA whether a 1031 exchange fits.