What sets the starting point?
Comparable sales. A comp is a house like yours that closed recently, close by. Everything else is an adjustment to that.
A useful comp matches on five things:
- Location. Same neighborhood or municipality, same school district, ideally within a few blocks.
- Type. A two-story to a two-story, a ranch to a ranch, a two-family flat to a two-family flat.
- Size. Close in finished square footage above grade. Basements count separately.
- Date. Closed in the last three to six months. Older sales need a market adjustment.
- Condition. Updated to updated, original to original.
I pull comps from MARIS, the St. Louis MLS. That matters more here than in most states. Missouri is a nondisclosure state for real estate sale prices (MOST Policy Initiative, February 2025). St. Louis City, St. Louis County and St. Charles County collect a certificate of value for the Assessor’s use, but the price is not printed on the public deed. The MLS is where the real numbers live.
How much does condition change the number?
More than anything except the comps themselves. In older St. Louis housing it can be the whole spread.
Buyers and appraisers sort condition into three rough groups:
- Renovated. New kitchen and baths, updated electrical and plumbing, newer roof and HVAC. Sells at the top of the comp range.
- Maintained. Clean, dated, everything works. Sells in the middle.
- Needs work. Deferred maintenance, original systems, something that will fail an inspection. Sells at the bottom, and sometimes only to a cash buyer.
A buyer does not subtract repairs at cost. They subtract cost, plus the hassle, plus a margin for what they cannot see. A roof that costs $12,000 to replace (a hypothetical figure) often costs a seller more than $12,000 in offers. That is the reason a few targeted repairs can pay, and it is also why I do the repair math before recommending any.
Why does location inside a submarket matter?
Because St. Louis prices change by the block, not by the zip code.
- A house facing Tower Grove Park is not the same comp as one six blocks south.
- A house on Gravois, Big Bend or Kingshighway sells for less than the same house one street in, because of traffic.
- Walking distance to a business district, such as South Grand or Old Webster, carries a premium that fades within a few blocks.
- A municipal line or a school district line can run down the middle of a street. The houses look the same. The tax bills and the buyer pools differ.
- A mapped flood zone changes the insurance cost, which changes what a buyer can pay.
How do age and old systems affect value?
St. Louis is built of brick, and a lot of it is 70 to 120 years old. Age by itself does not hurt value. Deferred systems do.
These are the items buyers and inspectors price in:
- Roof. Age and type. Flat roofs on city flats have shorter lives than pitched roofs.
- Tuckpointing. Missing mortar means water in the wall.
- Foundation. Stone foundations before the 1920s, poured or block after. Moisture and movement both show.
- Electrical. Knob-and-tube wiring, fuse boxes and 60-amp service can affect insurance and loans.
- Plumbing. Galvanized or lead supply lines, cast-iron stacks.
- Sewer lateral. Clay pipe from the house to the main. Most buyers scope it now.
- HVAC and water heater. Age is printed on the unit. Buyers read it.
- Windows and lead paint. Federal lead disclosure applies to housing built before 1978.
A house with a recent roof, an updated panel and a clean sewer scope sells faster and closer to list, because the buyer has less to guess about. Keep your receipts and permits. They are worth money at the offer table.
Does the tax district change what a buyer pays?
Yes, through the monthly payment. Most buyers shop by payment, and the payment includes property tax.
Missouri taxes residential property on 19% of the Assessor’s appraised value, multiplied by the combined rate of every taxing district at that address. Rates differ by school district, fire district and municipality. Two houses at the same price in different districts can carry noticeably different tax bills, which moves the payment and the price a buyer can qualify for.
Two more local points:
- City or County. The City of St. Louis charges a 1% earnings tax on residents' wages. St. Louis County does not. Buyers weigh that with their CPA.
- Occupancy inspections. The City and unincorporated St. Louis County both require an inspection when occupancy changes, and many County municipalities run their own. Required repairs are a cost one side has to carry, so they show up in negotiation.
The mechanics are in St. Louis property tax explained.
What do the lot and the layout add or subtract?
Size is on the listing sheet. Layout is what buyers feel in the first two minutes.
Lot
- Off-street parking and a garage. In the City this is a real premium.
- A usable, level yard. A steep or flood-prone lot subtracts.
Layout
- Bedrooms and baths on the same floor. A second full bath is one of the larger single adjustments in a small house.
- Functional obsolescence. A bedroom you walk through to reach another, a bath only in the basement, a kitchen with no room for a table.
- Above grade and below grade. Finished basement space is worth less per square foot than space above ground. An appraiser counts them separately.
Does timing matter?
Yes, in three ways.
- Season. More buyers shop in spring and early summer. Fewer shop from Thanksgiving to New Year’s. A well-priced house sells in any month, but the buyer pool is smaller in winter.
- Rates. When mortgage rates rise, the same payment buys less house. Your lender, not me, quotes rates.
- Local supply. If three similar houses are for sale on your side of the neighborhood, you are priced against them. If there are none, you are the only choice.
Days on market varies a lot from one area to the next. See days on market by neighborhood. Value is a snapshot. The number I give you in November may not be the number in April.
Who actually sets the value?
Three parties, and each number is used for something different.
| Who | What they produce | What it is used for |
|---|---|---|
| The buyer | An offer | The sale price, if you accept it |
| The lender’s appraiser | An appraised value | The loan amount the lender will approve |
| The Assessor | An appraised value for tax | Your property tax bill |
The buyer sets market value. A house is worth what a ready, able buyer will pay with the house exposed to the open market. My list price is a prediction of that.
The appraiser is hired through the lender, not by you or me. The appraiser uses closed comps and adjusts for differences. If the appraised value is below the contract price, the lender bases the loan on the lower figure. Then the buyer and seller renegotiate, the buyer brings more cash, or the contract ends under its terms. A cash buyer has no lender and usually no appraisal.
The Assessor values every parcel for tax purposes. Missouri reassesses real estate in odd-numbered years. The Assessor uses mass appraisal, which means models and sales data, usually without going inside. That value can sit above or below market. It is the starting point for your tax bill, and a buyer should not treat it as a price. You can appeal it. The Assessor and the Board of Equalization decide appeals.
Why do online estimates miss in St. Louis?
Four reasons.
- No sale prices in the public record. Missouri is a nondisclosure state. Models work from MLS feeds where they have them, listing prices and tax records, and fill in the rest.
- Nobody went inside. The model sees bedrooms, baths, square feet and year built. It does not see the 1962 kitchen, the new roof or the wet basement. In old brick, that is most of the value.
- Mixed housing. A four-family flat, a renovated single and an estate house can share a block. Averaging them produces a number that fits none of them.
- Bad inputs. County records often have the wrong finished square footage or miss a bath. The estimate inherits the error.
Online estimates do best in subdivisions where the houses are alike and sell often. They do worst in the City and the inner ring. Treat an online estimate as a rough range, then check it against closed comps.
What can you change before you sell?
You cannot move the house or change the lot. You can change condition, presentation and price. Fix what would fail a loan or an occupancy inspection, then clean and paint. A full kitchen rarely returns its cost in the sale. Or change nothing and sell it as it stands, which has its own price. See cash offer vs. listing for how the two nets compare.
How do I find out what my house is worth?
Send me the address. Within one business day you get a pricing review: what the house should list for on the open market, the closed comps I used and the adjustments, and your estimated net.
You see the work, and you decide. There is no cost and no obligation. If I or anyone in my network would buy the house, I disclose in writing that I am a licensed Missouri agent before any contract is signed. Commission is negotiable and is set in the listing agreement.
Ask what your home is worth, see the sellers page, or call or text (314) 348-5331.
These are price opinions, not appraisals. A lender’s appraiser sets appraised value, the Assessor sets taxable value, and a title company confirms payoff and closing figures. This page is not legal, tax or lending advice.