Buy Sell Invest Learn The Record Text (314) 348-5331

Rent vs. buy: find your break-even year.

"Renting is throwing money away" is a sales line, not math. The real version: buying wins eventually in most St. Louis scenarios, the question is how many years "eventually" takes, and whether you’ll stay that long. This compares total wealth on both paths: the buyer builds equity but pays interest, taxes, and upkeep; the renter pays rent but invests the down payment and any monthly savings.

Your inputs

$
$
%
%
Assumptions (tap to adjust)
%
%
%
%
%
$
%
%
The verdict
Buying pulls ahead in year 12

Net wealth, year by year

Buyer wealth = home value − loan balance − selling costs. Renter wealth = down payment + closing costs + monthly savings, invested.
BuyingRenting
What this model assumes: the renter actually invests the difference every month (most people don’t, forced savings is a real, underrated benefit of a mortgage); appreciation and investment returns are smooth (they aren’t); rates stay fixed (a refi changes the picture); and you don’t remodel the kitchen. PMI is included until 20% equity, then drops. Maintenance at 1%/yr is a long-run average, old housing stock in Webster or Soulard can run hotter, newer West County stock cooler. If your break-even lands past the year you’d realistically move, renting is the financially defensible choice and no agent should tell you otherwise. This is an estimate, not financial advice.
Built by Tony LaRocca, Licensed Missouri Real Estate Agent #2020028630, Assumptions reviewed July 2026

Buying your first place?

Text me the price range you are thinking about. I will send back what you need saved and what the payment looks like. I reply within 24 hours.

Text (314) 348-5331How much to save