Rent vs. buy: find your break-even year.
"Renting is throwing money away" is a sales line, not math. The real version: buying wins eventually in most St. Louis scenarios, the question is how many years "eventually" takes, and whether you’ll stay that long. This compares total wealth on both paths: the buyer builds equity but pays interest, taxes, and upkeep; the renter pays rent but invests the down payment and any monthly savings.
Your inputs
$
$
%
%
Assumptions (tap to adjust)
%
%
%
%
%
$
%
%
The verdict
Buying pulls ahead in year 12
What this model assumes: the renter actually invests the difference every month (most people don’t, forced savings is a real, underrated benefit of a mortgage); appreciation and investment returns are smooth (they aren’t); rates stay fixed (a refi changes the picture); and you don’t remodel the kitchen. PMI is included until 20% equity, then drops. Maintenance at 1%/yr is a long-run average, old housing stock in Webster or Soulard can run hotter, newer West County stock cooler. If your break-even lands past the year you’d realistically move, renting is the financially defensible choice and no agent should tell you otherwise. This is an estimate, not financial advice.